Dog Advice

What’s the Best Dog Breed?

February 8, 2016 4

What’s the best breed for you?

If there’s one question I get asked most, it’s “What’s the best dog breed?” That question has about 340 answers depending on who you’re asking. What you should be asking instead is “What’s the best dog breed for me?”

We’re all different and picking the right dog breed for you shouldn’t be about which breed is the most popular at a certain time (especially because that breed was featured in a movie). There are lots of things to consider before you go looking for a dog. If you do a quick Google search, you’ll find lots of things you should consider before buying a dog. I’ve put together a short list of some things that might not cross your mind and may make you regret your decision because they weren’t taken into consideration beforehand.


Size and exercise

If you have a new year’s resolution that you want to get more active, get a gym membership you can flake out on but don’t select an active dog breed in hopes that you’ll suddenly become a star athlete. If you don’t run marathons now, getting a dog with a high energy level will not make you a more active person. Maybe initially it’ll help get your ass off the couch, but that won’t last for long. Many people choose to give up their dog because they don’t have the time to provide the daily exercise that their dog needs. Don’t make this mistake, it’ll be sad for both of you.

cute dog with rainbow sweatbands

image from 3milliondogs.com

In my opinion size is important, but not everything. There are plenty of small dogs who need lots of exercise and alternatively there are plenty of dogs that are perfect for the lazy dog owner. For me, personality is more important than size. Admittedly, I tend to prefer bigger dogs, but there are lots of little dogs I’ve met that have completely stolen my heart. You might find that size isn’t as important a factor as you initially thought, especially when you consider the other traits that dog may have.


Where do you live?

Do you live in a house or apartment? Are you in the country or somewhere in the urban jungle? Where you live can play an important factor on the dog breed that’s best for you.

Some dogs are bred to bark and for a lot of people that’s completely fine. They either put up with it, learn to ignore it or just don’t mind it. Excessive barking drives me nuts! My dogs howl (a lot) but they don’t bark. If someone walks in front of the house or knocks on the door, I’ll be lucky if they even lift their head from their pillow. I’m sure that there are people who hear my dogs howl and wonder how anyone could live with two dogs like that.

Big dog in house

image from wallpaperawesome.com

In any case, living in an apartment is pretty much out of the question for me. I live in a house with (thankfully) very friendly neighbours that I can hear talking to the girls through the fence after the girls howl a “Good morning” when they see them outside.

Usually they’re howling because they’re hungry, want to go for a walk or just pissed off and need to air their grievances. I think it’s funny and endearing, but you might absolutely hate it. The amount and type of noise your dog might make is something you should consider before trying to find your new best friend.


Hair or drool?

Malamutes shed like crazy. Every time I take them for a walk someone is bound to ask if they shed at all. I always sarcastically answer “No. I’ve never seen hair anywhere in my house.” In reality, I had to buy a Shop-Vac because my regular vacuum couldn’t handle all of the hair these two shed.

Siberian Husky shedding fur

image from siberian-huskies101.com

Even though I find hair in my house, on my clothes and even sometimes in my food, it doesn’t bother me. Regular grooming and house cleaning keeps the shedding under control. For the record, I now totally understand why my parents always insisted on poodle crosses when we were growing up.

Some dogs drool and while that might be fine for some dog owners, that’s where I personally draw the line. I’m okay with finding hair in weird places but I couldn’t handle finding random patches of drool in my house – yeck! So before you think about getting a Siberian Husky or Saint Bernard puppy, be real with yourself and what you can live with.


High achiever or loveable goofball?

Many people forget about the mental stimulation a dog needs. Owners will be dumbfounded why their house is being destroyed by a dog they exercise a lot. Sometimes the reason can be that your dog is just plain bored.

If you love a dog that you can teach tricks easily to and you feel will understand you, you might want to consider a smart dog breed. Keep in mind that these dogs will need more mental stimulation than a not-so-smart breed, but for the right owner, that can be absolutely perfect.

I feel like I’ve got a great mix in my house and I’ll be honest it was purely by chance. Dakota was from a farm in Alberta when I lived there in my early 20’s. Casey was a rescue who had a long story before she ended up in my home. They shed a lot, they can be noisy but I love them each dearly. I couldn’t have found a better pair of friends if I tried.

Before you go searching for a dog for your family, be honest with yourself. Take some time, talk to breeders, other dog owners and find one that’s just right for you. Having a dog is a lifetime commitment, not a hobby or a fad. Best of luck in finding your new best friend!

What makes you love your dog? Did you own that breed in the past? What criteria did you consider before getting the dog you have now? Share your thoughts in the comments below.

Greg Lehman on sabtwitterGreg Lehman on sablinkedinGreg Lehman on sabinstagram
Greg Lehman
Founder @ TuxedoMutt
Greg Lehman is a hippie in a business suit. He's also a positive based dog trainer and freelance writer. When he's not working, you'll find him somewhere in nature with his two dogs Casey and Dakota or taking a nap. Who doesn't love naps?

More TuxedoMutt Blogs You Might Enjoy


There are 4 comments

  • Jen says:

    I loved reading this! Thanks for posting

  • Greg Lehman says:

    Thanks Jen. So glad that you stopped by.

  • […] with anything, make sure you do your research first. Shedding hair is just one aspect of a dog breed. Get to know the dog entirely before you make a decision. You want a dog that suits your […]

  • […] you consider getting a dog, it’s important to be honest with yourself and the kind of lifestyle you have. Not all dogs can handle quiet, inactive homes and others […]